The best of non-profit advertising and marketing for social causes

Is it okay to make light of rape in the name of women’s rights?

Is it okay to make light of rape in the name of women’s rights?

WARNING: THIS POST CONTAINS VIDEO WHICH MAY BE OFFENSIVE TO SOME, EVEN TRAUMATIC TO SEXUAL ASSAULT SURVIVORS

LEGITIMATE_RAPE_PARODY

Representative Todd Akin, who is a Republican candidate for Senate in Missouri, recently defended his extreme anti-abortion stance to deny the procedure to victims of sexual assault by claiming that it was almost impossible to get pregnant from “legitimate rape”:

“It seems to me, from what I understand from doctors, that’s really rare,” Akin told KTVI-TV. “If it’s a legitimate rape, the female body has ways to try to shut that whole thing down. But let’s assume that maybe that didn’t work or something: I think there should be some punishment, but the punishment ought to be of the rapist, and not attacking the child.”

The comment ignited a firestorm of protest, both in terms of the bad science and extreme insensitivity involved.

But because this is the social media age, there were also more creative protests. One was this video by The Raging Grannies that got a lot of play:

Unfortunately, the conversation crossed the line in a birth control ad parody that I saw this morning. In it, a smiling woman is knocked to the ground and violently sexually assaulted while cheerfully extolling the virtues of “Legitimate Rape” as a contraceptive. The ad is complete with euphemistic flower visuals and a long list of side-effects, and a call to visit the Rape, Abuse & Incest National Network (RAINN) — even while claiming no affiliation with that group.

I get it. Swiftian social parody can be a very effective tool for inciting important public discussion about the big issues.

But in my opinion, rape is not just an “issue”. People who have been sexually assaulted — and let’s face it, most of them are women — have been physically and psychologically violated in a way that can cause lifelong trauma. Comedian Laura Napoli, who wrote and stars in the spot, I’m sure meant well. And comedy is not, as Steve Martin once said, “pretty”. But I’m concerned about the unintended consequences of this sketch.

Rep. Akin’s comments themselves caused some survivors to relive the trauma. One woman told Current:

“It was sickening. That’s the best way to describe how I felt about Akin’s comments. I was sick to my stomach. I am still sick to my stomach. But what makes it worse is that no one seems to have any regard for how these comments are actually impacting people who have already been victimized by rape. These comments are causing us to be triggered all over again.”

How would these women feel, watching their experiences reduced to a gag for a slapstick political statement?

I’d appreciate comments by people personally or professionally closer to the issue than I am.

Advertiser:
Legitimate Rape (parody Facebook page)
Agency:
Laura Napoli (writer, feature performer)
Additional credits:
EXECUTIVE PRODUCERS:
Laura Napoli
Joel Silberman

STARRING:
Laura Napoli

FIELD PRODUCER:
Ben Rock

EDITING PRODUCER:
Noah Pohl

WRITTEN BY:
Laura Napoli
Joel Silberman

ANIMATOR:
Mark Alkofer

COMPOSER AND SOUND DESIGNER:
Jordan Bennett

STUNT COORDINATOR/STUNTS:
Joshua Bradley

SOUND OPERATOR:
Greg Machlin

HAIR AND LIGHTING:
Clemence du Barre

LOGO DESIGNER:
Alyssa Weinberger
Source:
Copyranter

I am Creative Director at Acart Communications, a Canadian Social Issues Marketing agency. Read more
We respect your privacy. We try to keep the setting of cookies as low as possible - Information: Cookies policy.
Accept Cookies
x