Onstuimig

MADD still trying to shame kids out of drinking

Posted by Tom Megginson | 28-03-2012 18:49 | Category: Drugs



image

I’m not a fan of Mothers Against Drunk Driving. People look at me funny when I tell them that, but I simply don’t trust their motives. If they were focussed on convincing people not to drink drunk, I’d fully support them. But I tend to agree with Sociologist David J. Hanson that their true goal is nothing short of prohibition.

And so this new campaign tries to frighten teens out of drinking by telling them it will put them into bad situations when they inevitable pass out at a party.

The male one is kind of comical:

MADD - Shaved from Esparza Advertising on Vimeo.

The one featuring a young woman, however, puts her in a much more dangerous situation.

(More after the break.)


In research that might as well be permalinked to this site, The Kellogg School of Management concluded:

“...Viewers already feeling some level of guilt or shame instinctively resist messages that rely on those emotions, and in some cases are more likely to participate in the behavior they’re being warned about.

The reason, said Kellogg marketing professor Nidhi Agrawal, is that people who are already feeling guilt or shame resort to something called “defensive processing” when confronted with more of either, and tend to disassociate themselves with whatever they are being shown in order to lessen those emotions.

And it doesn’t have to be drinking that a viewer is feeling ashamed about in order to render the ads ineffective or damaging. ‘If you’re talking to a student about cheating on an exam, and one of these ads comes up, you can bet they are headed straight to the bar,’ said Ms. Agrawal, who conducted the study along with her Indiana University colleague, Adam Duhacheck.

Given that the shaming, consequence-centric approach is commonplace in any number of ads focused on smoking, steroid usage and sexually transmitted diseases, the ramifications of the findings could be significant. ‘There’s a lot of money spent on these ads that could be put to better use,’ she argues.”

In other words, these MADD ads are following in the footsteps of similar social marketing campaigns that have already proven to be worse than ineffective—even detrimental.

The second ad, which puts the responsibility on the rape victim not to get drunk, is also reminiscent of the Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board’s ”Control Tonight” campaign on binge drinking campaign:

image

Of that ad, “The image itself is very triggering for rape victims,” said Julie Mastrine, a junior from Penn State University. “But the message that it’s sending is one of victim-blaming. We live in a society that seems to preach, ‘Don’t get raped,’ instead of, ‘Don’t rape.’”

Following similar protests, that campaign was voluntarily pulled by the advertiser.

Will MADD do the same? I am doubtful. Those mothers have their own agenda.

Related MADD posts:
- Drinking and driving can mark you for life
- I’m not MADD about these ads
- Broken Teens
- Amy, Jenny, Jeff and Lisa
- Don’t make it a grad to forget


Advertiser:
Mothers Against Drunk Driving
Agency:
Esparza Advertising Albuquerque, New Mexico, USA
Additional credits:
Creative Director: Adam Greenhood
ACD: Jeremy Spencer
Art Director: Zak Rutledge
Production Company: Buffalo Picture House
Director: Felix Thompson
Producer: Gabrielle Nadig
Art Direction: Emmeline Wilks-Dupoise
Edit: Paul Penczner
DP: Brandon Roots
Source:
Adrants
Keywords:
-



Comments


Comments about MADD still trying to shame kids out of drinking

Thanks for the Crash Course link I’d heard and read a lot of the information before but to read it all in one place is truly overwhelming.

Posted by Sara | 29-03-2012 21:46



My comment



Comment:




Your comment will not be visible until a moderator approves it.








Some rights reserved 2005-2013 Osocio/Houtlust.
Disclaimer. Terms of use. Privacy statement.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 License.







Support us

Do you like our blog? Support us with a donation.
We're non-commercial. We all make Osocio pro bono in our spare time and we can use some support.





image of a graduation cap

Recent in Academy


Is this eating disorder ad too sexy?

It’s a serious question. This woman has the typical idealized body of a model, and despite the scary body painting, the portrayal is undeniably drawing attention to her curves and bare skin. When I think about eating disorders, I try to imagine looking in the mirror and seeing a funhouse…
Read more

Book review: Hidden Persuasion

33 psychological influence techniques in advertising Designing for behavior change is our thing here on Osocio.  We discuss the wide area of social campaigns from all over the world. ‘Is it a good or bad campaign’ is our first question. And we often judge a campaign based on professional principles…
Read more


About Osocio

Osocio is dedicated to social advertising and non-profit campaigns. It’s the place where marketing and activism collide. Formerly known as the Houtlust Blog, Osocio is the central online hub for advertisers, ad agencies, grassroots, activists, social entrepreneurs, and good Samaritans from around the globe.
Read more

(the about page is also available in Bahasa Indonesia, Chinese 汉语/漢語, Deutsch, Español, Français, Italiano, Nihongo 日本語, Ivrit עברית, Filipino, Polski, Português, Russian Русский язык, Slovenčina, Suomi, Svenska and Türkçe)